Close this search box.

What If I Have Pre-Existing Injuries Before My Personal Injury?

When you’ve been involved in an accident and suffered injuries, navigating the intricacies of a personal injury claim can be challenging. If you have pre-existing injuries, it might seem even more complex. Pre-existing injuries refer to any health condition or injury that was present before the accident occurred. These can range from chronic conditions like arthritis to prior physical traumas like old fractures. It’s essential to understand how these injuries might affect your claim, as they can impact the compensation you might receive.

How Do Pre-existing Injuries Impact Your Personal Injury Claim?

Pre-existing injuries refer to any health condition or injury present before the incident in question. This can encompass chronic conditions like arthritis or heart disease, past physical injuries, or even psychological conditions like depression or anxiety if they existed before the accident.

What are the common types of pre-existing injuries?

In personal injury claims, we often see a range of pre-existing injuries. These commonly include back and neck injuries, traumatic brain injuries, degenerative disc disease, and joint injuries. Conditions such as fibromyalgia, heart disorders, or past psychological trauma can also be relevant.

How do pre-existing injuries impact your health after an accident?

Pre-existing conditions might make you more vulnerable to additional injuries and can complicate the recovery process. An accident can exacerbate these conditions, potentially resulting in increased pain, extended healing time, or related health complications.

Does a pre-existing injury prevent you from pursuing compensation?

Despite the potential complexities, a pre-existing injury does not preclude you from seeking compensation in a personal injury claim. However, it underscores the need for proficient legal representation to accurately establish the extent and cause of your injuries following an accident.

What is the “Eggshell Skull” Rule in Personal Injury Law?

The “Eggshell Skull” rule is a fundamental principle in personal injury law. Named after a hypothetical scenario involving an individual with an unusually fragile skull, the rule establishes that a party cannot evade liability for injury simply because the victim was more susceptible due to a pre-existing condition.

How does the “eggshell skull” rule apply to pre-existing conditions?

In essence, this rule dictates that the at-fault party must “take their victims as they find them.” This means they are accountable for all consequences of their actions, even if a pre-existing condition of the injured party intensifies the resulting injury.

For example, if you have a pre-existing back issue that is exacerbated by a car accident, the rule prevents the at-fault party from reducing liability simply because your injury might be more severe than it would have been in an individual without your pre-existing condition.

Why is the “eggshell skull” rule important for your personal injury claim?

The application of the “Eggshell Skull” rule can be critical in personal injury cases involving pre-existing conditions. It ensures victims receive fair compensation based on their actual suffering, rather than what might have occurred in an “average” person without a pre-existing condition. Understanding and effectively utilizing this rule is crucial when pursuing a personal injury claim with pre-existing conditions.

How Are Pre-existing Injuries Viewed by Insurance Companies in Personal Injury Claims?

Insurance companies often scrutinize pre-existing injuries during personal injury claims. They may claim that the injuries you suffered from the incident are primarily due to your pre-existing condition, not the accident itself. This perspective may lead to lower settlement offers, as they assert the incident isn’t wholly responsible for your current suffering.

Can insurance companies use pre-existing injuries to lower compensation?

Indeed, insurance companies may utilize your medical history to minimize the perceived impact of the accident, subsequently offering a smaller settlement. For instance, they might suggest your back pain from a car accident is merely an exacerbation of a pre-existing condition, rather than a new injury.

How can an attorney advocate for fair treatment?

Despite these complexities, a proficient personal injury attorney can work towards fair treatment. They can distinguish the effects of your pre-existing injuries from the new injuries caused by the accident. They will collect relevant medical evidence, consult medical experts, and use legal strategies such as the “Eggshell Skull” rule to counter the insurance company’s attempts to devalue your claim.

Having pre-existing injuries should not deter you from receiving full compensation for any new injuries or worsened pre-existing conditions due to the accident. An experienced attorney can guide you through this intricate process, ensuring your pre-existing conditions are not used unjustly against you.

Why Is Full Disclosure of Pre-existing Injuries Crucial in a Personal Injury Claim?

Disclosing your pre-existing injuries to your attorney is paramount when pursuing a personal injury claim. Full disclosure allows your attorney to accurately assess your case, prepare a solid legal strategy, and anticipate potential arguments from the opposing side. Without a complete understanding of your medical history, your attorney might be caught off guard by information brought forth by the defense, which could negatively impact your claim.

The legal and ethical implications of non-disclosure

Failing to disclose pre-existing injuries can have severe legal and ethical consequences. It can be perceived as deceitful and undermine your credibility in court. Additionally, if it’s discovered that you knowingly withheld this information, it could lead to dismissal of your case, and in some instances, legal penalties.

Medical records as the baseline for your health status

Medical records play a crucial role in establishing your baseline health status before the accident. These records can help differentiate the injuries sustained from the accident from your pre-existing conditions. Therefore, they serve as vital evidence in determining the extent to which the accident exacerbated your pre-existing injuries or caused new ones.

Full disclosure is not about jeopardizing your claim, but rather about equipping your attorney with all the necessary information to advocate effectively for your rights and ensure you receive the compensation you deserve.

What Are Effective Strategies for Handling Pre-existing Injuries in Personal Injury Claims?


Effectively handling pre-existing injuries in personal injury claims requires a comprehensive strategy. Key steps include obtaining detailed medical documentation, consulting with medical experts to differentiate between your pre-existing conditions and new injuries, and clearly demonstrating how the accident aggravated your pre-existing conditions. Remember, every case is unique, so consult with a personal injury attorney to determine the best approach for your situation.

The role of comprehensive medical documentation

Obtaining and providing thorough medical documentation is a crucial strategy in handling pre-existing injuries in a personal injury claim. This includes records from your physicians, specialists, physical therapists, and any other healthcare providers you’ve visited. This comprehensive documentation helps to establish a clear picture of your health status prior to the accident and any changes or complications that arose due to the incident.

The importance of consulting medical experts

Consulting medical experts can be invaluable in distinguishing between pre-existing injuries and those resulting from the accident. These experts can offer professional opinions on how the accident may have impacted your pre-existing condition or contributed to new injuries. Their testimonies can provide crucial evidence to support your claim.

Demonstrating the impact of the accident on your pre-existing condition

One of the primary tasks in a personal injury claim involving pre-existing injuries is to clearly demonstrate that the accident exacerbated or aggravated these conditions. This could mean that the accident led to a worsening of symptoms, delayed recovery, or increased medical care needs. By systematically presenting this information, you can make a compelling argument that the accident has had a significant impact on your health, and thus you deserve appropriate compensation.

Remember, every case is unique, and it’s crucial to discuss your specific circumstances with a qualified personal injury attorney to determine the best strategy for your situation.

Need Expert Help to Navigate Your Personal Injury Claim with Pre-existing Injuries?


Navigating a personal injury claim involving pre-existing injuries can be a complex process. It requires not only an understanding of legal principles like the “Eggshell Skull” rule but also a keen ability to negotiate with insurance companies and possibly argue your case in court. An experienced personal injury attorney can provide the guidance, strategy, and representation you need to advocate for your rights and seek fair compensation.

At our law firm, we have a wealth of experience in handling personal injury cases with pre-existing conditions. We understand the nuances of these cases, and we’re ready to fight for you.

Don’t let pre-existing conditions deter you from pursuing the justice and compensation you deserve. Reach out to us for a free consultation. Let’s discuss your case and explore the best strategies to secure a favorable outcome. We’re here to help. Don’t wait—contact us today.



Response time within minutes