When you’re involved in a car accident in San Diego, one of the first questions you’ll likely have is: “Who decides who’s at fault?” This determination is not just about blame—it directly impacts whose insurance pays for damages, medical bills, and other losses. Understanding how fault is determined in California can help you protect your rights and take the proper steps following a crash.
We are San Diego’s Award-winning personal injury law firm. In the last three years, our San Diego personal injury lawyers have won tens of millions in settlements and verdicts for our clients. HHJ Trial Attorneys have been featured in the San Diego local news (ABC 10News San Diego) for recovering some of most challenging personal injury cases in southern California.
Defense offered $350,000 before trial
Defense offered $0 before trial. Largest therapist sexual abuse jury verdict in San Diego County.
Defendants offer was $150,000 before trial. We got 17 times the offer at trial for our client.
California operates under an “at-fault” or “tort” system when it comes to car accidents. This means the driver who caused the accident is financially responsible for any resulting damages. Unlike no-fault states, where each driver’s own insurance pays for their losses regardless of who caused the crash, California requires a thorough investigation to identify the responsible party.
In the aftermath of an accident, fault can be clear-cut or hotly contested. The process of determining it involves a combination of reports, evidence, and sometimes, legal proceedings.
When police are called to the scene of an accident in San Diego, they typically file an official collision report. This document includes:
The officer’s observations
Diagrams of the accident
Witness statements
Any citations issued
While police officers do not have the final say in who is legally at fault, their report often carries significant weight. Insurance companies frequently rely on these findings during their investigations. If the officer notes that one driver violated a traffic law—for instance, running a red light or failing to yield—that can strongly influence the decision on fault.
However, it’s important to know that a police report is not conclusive. Even if you are listed as the at-fault party in the report, you may still contest it with additional evidence or through legal representation.
Insurance companies play a central role in the fault determination process. After a claim is filed, each involved party’s insurance carrier will conduct its own investigation. This typically includes:
Reviewing the police report
Inspecting vehicle damage
Interviewing drivers and passengers
Contacting witnesses
Examining photos or video evidence from the scene
Each insurer may come to its own conclusion about fault. This is where things can get complicated—especially if the two insurance companies disagree. If both sides stick to their stance, the dispute can delay compensation or even lead to a lawsuit.
California law allows for comparative negligence, which means more than one party can share responsibility. For example, if you’re found to be 20% at fault and the other driver is 80% at fault, your compensation would be reduced by 20%. This system underscores the importance of carefully documenting the accident scene and protecting your legal interests.
In some cases, the parties involved in a San Diego car accident cannot reach an agreement through insurance claims alone. If settlement negotiations fail, the case may end up in civil court. Here, a judge or jury will review the evidence and determine liability.
Lawsuits may be filed when:
Insurance companies refuse to accept liability
Damages exceed insurance policy limits
Injuries are severe or long-lasting
One party believes the fault assessment is unfair
Once in court, legal teams for both sides will present evidence, including expert testimony, accident reconstructions, and medical records. The judge or jury will then decide who is responsible and what compensation is owed.
Hiring an experienced personal injury attorney can make a significant difference in these cases. They can help gather the necessary evidence, negotiate with insurers, and represent you in court if needed.
