HHJ Trial Attorneys

San Diego Car Accidents & Injury Lawyers

Close this search box.

Truck Driver Fatigue and Liability in Accidents: Do I Have a Case?

Truck driver fatigue is a significant yet often overlooked cause of road accidents. This weariness results from extended hours behind the wheel and insufficient rest, severely impairing a driver’s reaction time and decision-making abilities – elevating the risk of accidents.


We aim to inform the public, particularly those impacted by truck driver accidents, about their legal rights and the complexities of seeking justice and compensation in these cases. Allow our San Diego truck accident lawyers to help you navigate the ins and outs of liability when it comes to truck accidents.

What Is Truck Driver Fatigue?

Driver fatigue is a state of exhaustion that impairs a driver’s alertness and performance, often marked by symptoms like drowsiness, slow reaction times, and diminished decision-making ability.


This fatigue typically stems from prolonged driving hours, inadequate rest, and the pressure to meet tight delivery schedules. Studies highlight the alarming prevalence of this issue; for instance, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration reports that fatigue contributes to approximately 30-40% of all heavy truck accidents.


These statistics underscore the critical nature of fatigue in truck driving, highlighting its significant impact on road safety and the pressing need to address this challenge.

Legal Standards and Regulations

Strict laws and regulations designed to mitigate driver fatigue govern the trucking industry. Chief among these are the Hours of Service (HOS) regulations, enforced by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), which dictate maximum driving hours and mandatory rest periods for truck drivers.


These rules limit drivers to 11 hours of driving within a 14-hour workday, followed by a required 10-hour off-duty period. In truck accident cases, compliance with these regulations is a critical factor.


Violations can indicate negligence, influencing liability determinations. These laws promote road safety and serve as a legal framework for assessing responsibility in truck-related accidents.

What Is the Role of Fatigue in Truck Accidents?

Numerous case studies demonstrate that fatigue plays a crucial role in truck accidents. For instance, a notable accident investigation revealed that the truck driver’s prolonged hours without adequate rest directly led to a severe collision.


Fatigue drastically impairs a truck driver’s operational capabilities, affecting reaction time, judgment, and overall alertness. Experts in the field concur, with studies showing that driving fatigued exhibits performance similar to those with elevated blood alcohol levels.


These findings highlight the dangerous implications of fatigue on driving performance, emphasizing the need for stringent adherence to rest guidelines to ensure road safety.

Determining Liability in Fatigue-Related Accidents

Determining liability in fatigue-related truck accidents involves a nuanced legal analysis. Primarily, it requires establishing that the driver’s fatigue significantly contributed to the accident. This process often hinges on various forms of evidence.


Logbooks are scrutinized to check compliance with Hours of Service regulations, and witness statements can offer insights into the driver’s behavior and condition before the accident.


Electronic logging devices (ELDs), which are mandatory in most commercial trucks, provide accurate and tamper-resistant records of driving hours, further aiding in this investigation. Liability can extend beyond the truck driver.


The trucking company may be accountable, especially if it encourages or ignores regulation violations. Third parties responsible for loading the truck or setting unrealistic delivery schedules can also share liability if their actions contributed to the driver’s fatigue.


Thus, in these complex cases, multiple parties may be responsible, each with varying liability based on their contribution to the circumstances leading to the accident.

What Are Your Rights as an Accident Victim?

You are entitled to legal rights that are crucial for seeking justice and compensation. Firstly, you can claim compensation for various damages, including medical expenses, lost wages due to inability to work, and pain and suffering.


In cases involving fatalities, families may seek wrongful death damages. The complexity of truck accident cases, especially those involving driver fatigue, underscores the importance of legal representation.



Response time within minutes